Now accepting holiday orders — November dates open.

Custom Celebration Cakes

Cakes worth
celebrating.

Custom cakes with familiar flavors, thoughtful fillings, and plenty of personality.

A custom yellow-and-white striped cake decorated with buttercream, colorful sprinkles, and candied oranges

Tried one of our treats?

Share your feedback — help shape our next free tasting bake.

Leave feedback

How it works

A simple, considered process — from first message to first slice.

01

Tell us about your celebration

Share the date, occasion, servings, and any flavor or design ideas floating in your head.

02

We'll collaborate on the design

We'll trade inspiration, refine the concept, and shape a cake that feels distinctly yours.

03

We'll confirm availability and finalize

Once details, pricing, and deposit are set, your date is officially on the calendar.

Portfolio

See our full portfolio on Instagram.

@buttersugarsisters

Cake inquiry

Tell us about your cake.

The more you can share, the better. We'll be in touch within a few days to confirm availability and next steps. Our cakes start at $95.

Please note:

Your cake can be filled with a variety of delicious buttercreams, whipped ganaches, and fruit fillings. Under Illinois cottage food rules, certain fillings—such as uncooked custard, pastry cream, and raw-egg fillings—cannot be offered. All recipes containing eggs, including our buttercream frostings, are cooked to a safe temperature.

Delivery is only available within a 20-minute drive of Western Springs, IL.

Your inquiry will be sent to buttersugarsisters@gmail.com.

Tasting feedback

Tried one of our treats? Tell us what you thought.

We're baking a few things for free to gather honest feedback and share new work. Your notes help us make the next round even better.

Your feedback will be sent to buttersugarsisters@gmail.com.